Currently
39°
Clear

Advertisement





News

CLASSIFIEDS


Advertisement


Free Ad

Place an ad
in print and online, 24/7 for free, select the Clean Sweep option. Unable to submit Real Estate, Services, and Business Investements at this time.

Get a Subscription


Map the Valley


Subscriber/
Reader Services

Subscribe Now
Contact Customer Service



Trial under way for Christensen

Former Hanford City Manager Alan Christensen went on criminal trial on misdemeanor fraud and grand theft charges Monday. Michael Reinhart, Kings County's prosecutor in the case, said Christensen "betrayed the trust" of city taxpayers when he tampered with numbers in the documents used to get his moving expenses reimbursed.

In his opening statements, Reinhart told how Christensen falsified documents and lied about it to the city's finance director, Tom Dibble, and overcharged the city by about $1,000 in moving expenses allowed under his employment contract.

"We'll prove to you this was not simply a mistake," Reinhart told a jury of nine women and three men. "This was intentional."

Christensen's lawyer, Carl Faller, portrayed his client as a responsible family man and also as a victim of dissension within the ranks of his administration. He raised questions about three of his subordinates who banded together to turn him in to state authorities for criminal investigation rather than consulting with the city council or city attorney. Faller also claimed that the reimbursement process was vaguely worded in the contract.

Faller told the jurors that his client, who was under pressure to move his family from Bakersfield up to Hanford while dealing with his father's failing health, did make a "stupid mistake" in the chaos of his situation.

Charges stem from allegations that Christensen changed a low bid of $7,050 to $7,850 submitted by Allied Van Lines of Bakersfield in order to hire an apparent low bidder, Galbraith Van & Storage that submitted an unfixed bid of $7,600 and ultimately caused the city to reimburse him for $8,100.

Under his contract, Christensen was required to seek three bids and take the lowest.

"In the midst of things he did a very stupid thing. He changed the zero to an eight on an Alllied bid," Faller said, adding that Christensen changed the numbers himself because he thought he missed the lowest bid's deadline.

Also, when contacted by a state Department of Justice agent in May 2007, Christensen "freaked" and denied the allegation, Faller said.

"That was the second huge mistake he made," Faller said, following up with statements that Christensen wasn't trying to pocket any money.

"We'll show that no crime was committed by Alan Christensen," Faller said.

Christensen, 46, faces two misdemeanor charges for fraud and grand theft. He was city manager for Hanford from August 2006 to May 2007, before resigning abruptly with no explanation only nine months into his job.

If convicted, he could face one year in county jail; Christensen's defense lawyer and prosecutors had not been able to reach any resolution before trial.

Christensen, donning a dark blue suit, sat quietly during testimony of those who worked under him, which was scheduled to continue today. Christensen, who now lives in Bakersfield, is currently the city manager of Arvin.

The trial is expected to last for two or three days, and any more than that is unlikely, visiting Judge Timothy Buckley said during the jury selection process.

On Monday, the jury listened to testimony from City Clerk Karen Madruga and City Finance Director Tom Dibble, as well as Ben Durham, sales manager of the Allied moving firm.

Today, the trial will resume with testimony by Deputy City Manager Mary Lindsay. Other witnesses, including Deputy City Manager Tom Haglund, are expected to testify about how Christensen claimed $1,000 more than he should have on his moving expenses and breached the terms of his contract.

Dibble, Lindsay and Haglund were the three who took the case to Kings County Sheriff Chris Jordan, a former Hanford Police Department captain, who then forwarded the matter to the state Department of Justice. Haglund was among the candidates vying for the city manager position when Christensen was hired.

Sentinel reporter Joe Johnson contributed to this report.

The reporter can be reached at 583-2429.

(March 25, 2008)

POST A COMMENT

 

Hanfordsentinel.com encourages readers to engage in civil conversation with their neighbors. Comments that are submitted are not posted to the site immediately. They go into a queue to be moderated and may take several hours to be reviewed, particularly if they are posted after normal office hours.

We reserve the right to remove comments in total that violate our code of conduct. If you want to report a violation, please e-mail editor@HanfordSentinel.com

For more information please read our Terms of use, and Rules of the Road.

 


Please log in to post comments
*Member ID:
*Password:
  Forgot Your Password?
 
If you don't have an account you can create one for free by clicking the link below.
CREATE ACCOUNT
The following are comments from the readers. In no way do they represent the views of the Hanford Sentinel

Girl Friday wrote on Mar 25, 2008 2:35 PM:

" What a dumb waste of more money just from reading this first day you can see the silly Hanford City Goverment at there worst this was a matter that could have been questioned and done with at the time the "three Stooges" found it or was there more to it were they Dibble,Lindsay and Haglund soooooo afraid of someone new comming in that they were knit picking to get rid of this well qualified gentle family man??????? Thanks Sentinel for clarifing that Haglund was up for the job "

The Oracle Says... wrote on Mar 25, 2008 4:16 PM:

" He intentionally changed numbers on an expense form, then lied to an investigator about it....BUT, "We'll show he didnt commit any crime?"
RIIIIGHT....You screw around with public funds, cheat the system, lie to investigators when caught, and you dont want any accountability for it? Get real. Fact is he knew better. Should have just fessed up when caught, but when you lie and deny, its going to be game on. Its called public official accountability, and as a taxpayer, its what I expect and demand with my tax dollars "

to Girl Friday: wrote on Mar 25, 2008 6:05 PM:

" Did you actually read the article? CHRISTENSEN changed the document, lied about it to staff and then later lied again to the DOJ investigator. And this is supposed to be about how the people who turned him in are wrong? Do you want someone who lies and steals to be in charge of the City? You consider lying and stealing from public funds to be "knit picking"? (BTW, it should be nit picking - a "nit" being a small insect.) This "well qualified gentle family man" lied and kept lying when questioned. Should the staff have kept silent and let him get away with it? Wouldn't that have been covering up? Then what kind of harsh words would you have had? Are you trying to send the message that in the future anyone knowing of a crime should just keep quiet if the person committing it is a gentle family man? Maybe you are the silly one. "

I agree with Girl Friday wrote on Mar 25, 2008 7:03 PM:

" Political motivation to turn him in by Lindsay and her crew? I think yes. "

citizen kane wrote on Mar 25, 2008 7:33 PM:

" Mark my words, as the trial continues , Reinhart will break down and cry to the jury , YOU MUST CONVICT!!!!! "

"to Dumb Girl Friday" wrote on Mar 26, 2008 1:20 AM:

" Not reporting a crime is a crime. Three heroes, not stooges. "

Tony Mani wrote on Mar 26, 2008 7:52 AM:

" The way this city is run is becoming comical, and I'm not just talking about the city counsel. I'm also referring to the HESD board, the DA's office, the police department, etc. Seriously I’ve seen more organization on a playground than I have in how this town operates. It’s like a mafia, but in the country. This whole town needs an enema, and I think they should stick the hose right in the city counsel. "

Ex-Hanfordite wrote on Mar 26, 2008 9:09 AM:

" You, this BS waste of time and money is just INSANE. I hope you know where your property taxes are going. City of Hanford to include PD have done just about what ever the hec they want for MANY years. There needs to be some accountability. Not only is this a crap case, everyone who persued it and pushed it, should be fined the $80000+ cost in man hours. The jury should just walk out. I would and have done it before. I miss living in hanford, and visit friend and family almost weekly, but I will never live there agein "

Ex-Hanfordite wrote on Mar 26, 2008 9:10 AM:

" You, this BS waste of time and money is just INSANE. I hope you know where your property taxes are going. City of Hanford to include PD have done just about what ever the hec they want for MANY years. There needs to be some accountability. Not only is this a crap case, everyone who persued it and pushed it, should be fined the $80000+ cost in man hours. I would and have done it before. I miss living in hanford, and visit friend and family almost weekly, but I will never live there agein "

Hmmmmmmmm wrote on Mar 26, 2008 12:44 PM:

" Only Heroes because he was stepping on too many toes down there. With all the other BS that goes on with City Council, new City Manager, and employees. Come on it wasn't about the money, they could have just requested it back they wanted him out of the way so certain other people could take over. Mission accomplished! "

To Tony Mani wrote on Mar 26, 2008 4:27 PM:

" Why don't you run for office, Mr. Mani? Sounds like you have the crystal ball. "

had to be thier wrote on Mar 26, 2008 5:09 PM:

" " This was a waste of money, people could not convince me that he changed a document with intent to defraud for money! He gained nothing but a move that was promised to him in his contract and approved by the city. " "

Amused Observer wrote on Mar 26, 2008 8:24 PM:

" I don't know if Christensen is guilty or not. I don't know if Reynolds is guilty or not. But, I do know that for some reason Reynolds resigned /retired or whatever they called it. Then Christensen enters the picture. But, for some reason he also resigned. Then enters Misenhimer. Hmmm. Seems he's worked for the city for a number of years and he gets the job. Seems he's working out fine so much so that he got a nice hefty raise. I'm sure he's on board for the long haul. Now they're all one big happy family supporting one another through all of the idiotic decisions the council makes. If Christensen & Reynolds are guilty then they should be punished. I can't help but wonder if Reynolds and Christensen fell out of favor because they didn't go along with the program. "

CC Watchdog wrote on Mar 26, 2008 10:18 PM:

" Well folks have you heard mis-trial was declared in this case with the first jury. But they are already saying this isn't the end. We are gonna end up spending six figures to do what return the measley $1100.00 that has already been returned. Will the city not be satisfied until they have their pound of flesh? The guy lied, cheated, and the only mistake he made is unlike the rest of the City Gang he was caught. He left a paper trail, follow the money that's what I've said all along. We are setting here with a brand new school we can't utilize because the money isn't available and we are gonna waste hundreds of throusands of dollars to do what people? So what the City proves they don't know how to interview and hire people, do necessary background checks, if this guy hadn't stolen before then maybe it was a mistake, a stupid mistake but a mistake still the same. I don't understand we put our gardners through the mill but our City Manager just needs the stamp of approval of the CC who agreed to the expenses. "

CC Watchdog wrote on Mar 26, 2008 10:27 PM:

" The guy moved his family 90 miles why did we pay to move him and his family to begin with, a simple U-haul and some strong backs would have accomplished the same thing. When I moved from Southern California back to Hanford that is how I did it and the move was at least 140 Miles further. Spent a total of about $350.00 for rental and fuel. I just don't get it, brown baggers can't afford lunch and the white shirts put it on their expense accounts. I know I use to be a white shirt but I have been a brown bagger too, guess that's why I don't understand why the higher paid employee gets to eat for free. The guy/girl that bust his/her hump pays for everything, good system if you aren't a brown bagger. Well folks stay tuned for the on going saga of Peyton Place and how things should not be done. Tune in next week where the Chief of Police donates our new armored vehicle to the Kindergarden class at Lee Richmond School, they've got a large problem with armored fleas on the playground. "

Girl Friday wrote on Mar 27, 2008 7:26 AM:

" I am not even sure who I am responding to ;as It or should I say NIT didn't sign in' By the way my grandmother called it Knit Picking as she liked to drop a stitch here and there as needed the Southern Lady in here thought it was much nicer than picking bugs off!!!!!! Again I say no money was gained the matter could have been handled in the office the faxes and facts where there, error yes intent to profit or steal no. Good day NIT! and yes he is a good gentle family man "

Agog wrote on Mar 27, 2008 7:47 AM:

" All of you should now read the article about Christensen's fate being in the hands of the jury. He never pocketed ANY money.

The alleged crime was that there was a difference between the low bid and what the city actually paid. Christensen re-paid the City for the difference.

He said under oath that he told Dibble he was taking the higher bid. It never gives Dibble's response, which would have been interesting to know.

So an alleged crime of NO gain to the defendant is of such high profile significance that Lindsay felt she had to go straight to criminal channels instead of the usual procedures? There was obviously an axe to grind here, no matter WHAT Christensen did wrong in the end.

And he did NOT continue lying. He came forward after lying to change his statement. He could have let it ride. Only a man with conscience does that. Especially when changing the numbers was really the only "crime" that was committed - and he is now admitting to that!? How did he personally benefit from any of this?

"

to CC wrote on Mar 27, 2008 3:00 PM:

"
Why did we pay to move him 90 miles?? Because there was and IS no one qualified in this lame town to run Hanford. That's why we paid-- and should PAY to bring him back!! Also-- the reality of the business world is that CEO's (which is what a City Manager is) do get contracts that include many benefits like moving expenses. We actually got off cheap. Sometimes these contracts can contain a lot more benefits - or unreasonable salaries like the current underqualified city manager. "

CC Watchdog wrote on Mar 27, 2008 5:17 PM:

" Dear responder to CC who doesn't identify theirselves with a name of any kind. With your brillant reason for dismissing the charges against Christensen let's take it a step farther. Let's drop all charges against Mr. Reynolds go on the basis he is entitled as CEO of Hanford to a Golden Parachute which happens with CEO's all the time. We need pay the money he didn't accept and reinstate him if he pleases according to your logic. Both men should be released the charges exponged and the matters dropped because it was lack of wording in paperwork, fuzzy details and a stamp of approval from the County Council who allowed this to happen. If clarity in a description for reimbursement exists why wasn't it clarified before this happened. If a contract was in existance prior to negotiations why didn't a single council member have a copy of it or tried to get one. I don't understand why people who have an unobstructed view can't see, I suggest you visit your optomitrist immediately. Thank God the city council may not work, but justice still does. "

CC Watchdog wrote on Mar 27, 2008 5:29 PM:

" Council Members need to start being held accountable for their actions, it isn't trials we need in Hanford it is recalls of council members that's desperately needed. Thomas Jefferson once wrote - "A government big enough to give you everything you want, is big enough to take away everything you have." Folks don't you see it coming? We have a Senator running for President that doesn't think it is necessary for him to hold his hand over his heart during the National Anthem or Pledge of Allegiance every five year old in America knows that is terribly wrong. God for bid if he is elected is he gonna refuse to take the oath of office and put his hand on a bible and show his true colors? Come on we have a problem in this country with accountability and it starts at the top but has filtered down to every level of government. I remember when the elected officials and their family members were examples for the community not part of the problem. Remember you can't be part of the problem and claim to be part of the solution. "

CC Watchdog wrote on Mar 27, 2008 5:44 PM:

" To Amused Oberver - the problem with Reynolds is he got things done. The problem with Christensen is he actually found fraud and wanted to investigate more city agencies and was forced to resign. Reynolds didn't bow his head and say yes master to the powers to be therefore they forced him to retire early. Christensen found problems and the council wanted them buried in the rubble with the rest of their bad decisions. I really wonder what a complete city wide audit might reveal about our administrators of this fine city? Don't you? We found more money to pay one of the good ol' boys who replaced Christensen but we can't afford to donate enough money to fix the landmark cannons next to the civic auditorium or for a Veteran's Day Parade or 4th of July Fireworks. A lot of city's provide the Fireworks our concil just provides entertainment through their rediculous decisions and expects us to feel good about it. I know we could just submit for a City credit card and pay for the Fireworks that way and leave them stuck with the bill, like Tucci did. "

CC Watchdob wrote on Mar 28, 2008 3:12 PM:

" Agog you pretty much hit the nail on the head, are you a carpernter? Tee Hee! Be careful the CC is finding out we don't approve of them, what's next a house to house search for bloggers? They seem to enjoy witch hunts, who hid the pea under which shell all at taxpayers expense. Thanks for your comments. Keep it up more wisdom is appreciated by some who see the BIG PICTURE at City Hall. Warning! Do not fax confidential faxes to the City Manager's Office they will be intercepted and narc'd on. "




Advertisement


HOT TOPICS

> More Hot Topics


MORE LOCAL NEWS

Lemoore:

    Selma:

    Kingsburg:



    PHOTO GALLERIES

    "More Photos

    Sentinel Photos (134) Albums

    Hanford Luminaria
    Hanford Luminaria
    Friday, November, 20 2009
    (6) Photos
    Hanford High vs Dinuba Waterpolo Final
    Hanford High vs Dinuba Waterpolo Final
    Wednesday, November, 18 2009
    (13) Photos
    Fire on Hawk Street
    Fire on Hawk Street
    Wednesday, November, 18 2009
    (11) Photos

    Reader Submitted (7) Albums

    Vintage Hanford
    Vintage Hanford
    Monday, December, 15 2008
    (1) Photos
    Vacation Photos
    Vacation Photos
    Thursday, November, 20 2008
    (37) Photos
    Events
    Events
    Thursday, November, 20 2008
    (38) Photos

    More



    EMAIL UPDATES

    Sign up today to get all your local headlines delivered to your home or work e-mail address, so you don't miss the latest in breaking and local news.
    E-Mail:
    Daily News Updates
    Breaking News Alerts