Currently
54°
Showers

Advertisement





Opinion

CLASSIFIEDS


Advertisement


Free Ad

Place an ad
in print and online, 24/7 for free, select the Clean Sweep option. Unable to submit Real Estate, Services, and Business Investements at this time.

Get a Subscription


Map the Valley


Subscriber/
Reader Services

Subscribe Now
Contact Customer Service



Another View: How the Golden State got tarnished

To understand why the woes of California’s economy threaten the nation’s, we must understand the state’s road to insolvency. The Age of Reagan did not commence with the Great Communicator’s inauguration in 1981. For its real beginning, we need to go back to June 1978, when Californians went to the polls and enacted Proposition 13.

By passing Howard Jarvis’ maligned initiative, California voters reduced the Golden State to baser metal. Under Republican Gov. Earl Warren and Democratic Gov. Pat Brown, California epitomized the postwar American dream. Its public schools, from kindergarten through Berkeley and UCLA, were the nation’s finest; its roads and aqueducts the most efficient at moving cars and water ” the state’s lifeblood ” to their destinations. All this was funded by some of the nation’s highest taxes, which fell in good measure on the state’s flourishing banks and corporations.

Amid the inflation of the late 1970s, however, the California model began to crumple. As incomes and property values rose, Sacramento’s tax revenue soared ” but the parsimonious Democratic governor, Jerry Brown, neither spent those funds nor rebated them. With the state sitting on a $5 billion surplus, frustrated Californians grumped to the polls and passed Proposition 13, which rolled back and then froze property taxes ” effectively destroying the funding base of local governments and school districts, which thereafter depended largely on Sacramento for their revenue. Ranked fifth among the states in per-pupil spending during the 1950s and ‘60s, California sank to Mississippi-like levels ” the mid-40s ” by the 1990s.

Since 1978, state and local government in California has been funded chiefly by personal income taxes. Bank and corporation taxes have been steadily reduced. In the current recession, with state unemployment at 11 percent, tax revenue has fallen off a cliff.

But the problem with Proposition 13 wasn’t merely that it reduced revenue. It also made it very difficult to increase revenue. Raising taxes now requires a two-thirds vote of the Legislature, though in 47 other states a simple majority suffices. California has become overwhelmingly Democratic in the past two decades, but Republicans have managed to retain footholds ” representing just over one-third of the districts ” in both houses of the legislature.

The conservative backlash of 1978 also swept into the Legislature a new, proto-Reaganistic generation of Republicans, who dubbed themselves “the Neanderthals.” Compared to today’s GOP state legislators, though, the Neanderthals look like Diderot’s Encyclopedists. The current Republican crop has refused in good times as well as bad to raise business or other taxes (increasing the tobacco tax, for instance, has failed each of the past 14 times it has come up for a vote).

Abetted by little local Limbaughs who inflame Republican brains, they protest that the state already has the nation’s highest taxes. In fact, California ranks 18th among the states in percentage of personal income paid to state government, and its presumably beleaguered wealthiest 1 percent, according to Citizens for Tax Justice, pays just 7.4 percent of their income to the state, while the poorest Californians pay 10.2 percent.

But the myth of soak-the-rich high taxation persists among Republicans ” so much so that the GOP front-runner to succeed Arnold Schwarzenegger in next year’s gubernatorial election, former eBay CEO Meg Whitman, is calling for cuts in business tax rates even though the state is staring at a $21 billion deficit that it somehow has to close. In short order, unless the federal government steps in with a bridge loan, the state will throw 940,000 poor children off its health-care rolls and lay off tens of thousands of teachers.

Because California is so much larger than any other state, and its unemployment rate among the nation’s highest, the collapse of its capacity to spend will counteract some of the effect of the federal stimulus and retard the nation’s recovery ” much as its aerospace slump retarded the recovery of the mid-1990s.

The Obama administration ignores California’s plight at its own ” and the nation’s ” peril. The nation’s banks are stuck with so much bad paper from California mortgages gone awry that a huge contraction in state spending would make their assets even more toxic. In the short term, the only way to avoid a further downturn may be a federal loan to the state.

A more permanent, homegrown solution to California’s woes (and it may take a state constitutional convention to get it) would require the state to eliminate the two-thirds threshold for enacting taxes, to repeal Proposition 13’s freeze on the value of commercial properties (some of which are still assessed at their 1978 levels) and to end the process of ballot-box budgeting through the initiative process, which is now more dominated by monied interests than the legislature ever was. In Washington, the Age of Reagan may have shuddered to an inglorious end, but we also need action from state governments ” and Sacramento in particular ” to move us toward a more sustainable economic future.

Meyerson is editor-at-large of American Prospect and the L.A. Weekly.

POST A COMMENT

 

Hanfordsentinel.com encourages readers to engage in civil conversation with their neighbors. Comments that are submitted are not posted to the site immediately. They go into a queue to be moderated and may take several hours to be reviewed, particularly if they are posted after normal office hours.

We reserve the right to remove comments in total that violate our code of conduct. If you want to report a violation, please e-mail editor@HanfordSentinel.com

For more information please read our Terms of use, and Rules of the Road.

 


Please log in to post comments
*Member ID:
*Password:
  Forgot Your Password?
 
If you don't have an account you can create one for free by clicking the link below.
CREATE ACCOUNT
The following are comments from the readers. In no way do they represent the views of the Hanford Sentinel

Scott Tucker wrote on May 28, 2009 11:09 AM:

" "Abetted by little local Limbaughs who inflame Republican brains"

At least two or three people immediately come to mind!

(They will no doubt retort with something petty like: "At least we ARE local!" Yup, it seems that they will cling to that silly argument forever.) "

Bobb wrote on May 28, 2009 1:49 PM:

" Typical quick fix for government agency's who cannot and will not manage their money- give them more. Aqueducts flowing with water? I guess Harold is not up on the issue of the Delta pumps being turned off. The gas tax has been put into the general budget for years. The state has robbed local agency's of their tax funds, such as AB-8 several years ago that took local special assessments district taxes to fund the schools. People pay local taxes, federal taxes,excise taxes, sales taxes and the list goes on forever. The legislators need to do their job and balance the budget even if it means a 10% cut to all programs. Unfunded initiatives should never be allowed on the ballot. "

The Oracle wrote on May 28, 2009 6:34 PM:

" Finally hearing our governator talking about cutting welfare...Its about time. Like I said, I HOPE California implodes. Then and only then will cuts be made to all of the social programs that have bankrupted this state. Think other liberal states are watching California? You bet they are. But gee, what ARE they going to do without the sea otter and snowy plover programs? I guess we will just have to get along without them "

Sid wrote on May 29, 2009 8:52 AM:

" All the article is about is a "not enough in taxes" and we are not taxed enough, not enough "revenue", etc., etc.

Yet not ONE WORD about TOO MUCH state government SPENDING!

Scott, what about your paying any significant taxes again as an American living abroad? You dodged that question repeatedly this tax season... "

NotHomeGrown wrote on May 29, 2009 12:45 PM:

" Scot Tucker, I hope that I am one those names that you are always thinking about, makes me feel proud!
Raise business taxes, sounds real good, that way more companies will fold up and move to a more lucrative work site, so then we get stuck with even less revenue, can't tax who isn't here. More unemployed, have to provide for them from the shrinking working man's income by taxing them more. Seems like a very vicious cycle to me. How about trying out the opposite, freeze or lower business taxes, so more companies come here, they therefore hire more people, more people buying stuff, which in turn creates more jobs, which in turn creates a larger tax pool.
I for one am for a flat tax, make everyone pay 10% on all income. No breaks, no loopholes, just simple math, 10%. Make $1.00 pay 10 cents. Make $1,000,000.00 pay $100,000.00. Tax people on Welfare also, and make it a requirement that they work for the money, even if it is picking up trash off the side of the road. "

Mrs.D wrote on May 29, 2009 2:56 PM:

" California should do what Japan does to their welfare receipents: make them work for it. Either picking up garbage from public parks and buildings to pruning trees. Whatever it takes to keep Japan clean, they'll do it for their "free money". "

Thoughts I confess wrote on May 30, 2009 12:36 PM:

" It never ceases to amaze me how the self-correction/bubble mechanics occurred in the U.S. economy; revealed, "lying for profit," cooking-the-books, catastrophic-policy makers within the federal and state governments. Industry/corporate businesses go unpunished for the unsound practices, allowed by the FEDs. Banking institutions, irresponsibly opened credit lines to CORPORATIONS, who primarily employed illegal workers. Then there were INSTITUTIONS, who practices allowed in false documents/ignoring status of individuals (Welcomed - millions of undocumented individuals, who brought other family members to apply for credit without the skills to manage the terms or even payback scheduled loan payments).

Of course there were U.S. citizens too, simply not credit worthy. Banks excessively gave credit freely across the board to unsound/risky candidates who defaulted and now want relief?

The future? Corrupt elected leaders continuing in office, supported by the cronyism of private business (who willing robbed the U.S. Treasury for their relief), these “for the sake of profit” forces openly control decision makers now.

Americans must strategize and force government to bring on jobs development returning our original industries stateside with fresh technological sustainability along with constitutional amendments regarding non-outsourcing or in-sourcing of foreign workers, loopholes must be plugged. "

Watchdog Fred wrote on May 31, 2009 8:35 PM:

" To: Scott Tucker wrote on May 28, 2009 11:09 AM:

Should I notify Dan Chin, when you're coming home so he can assign you a parking place? That is with the rest of the City Council! "

americantaxpayer wrote on Jun 1, 2009 1:35 AM:

" Proposition 13 was needed at that time. Property taxes where running out of control and making homeownership in California a nightmare for homeowners. I agree that the business properties need to be taxed at a different rate. California's main problem is it over spends every year and refuses to operate with in its collectable revenues. Its retirement system needs to be terminated and replaced with a 401k style retirement plan. Our prison system needs to be cut in half with less perks for the prisoners. No TV or medical care! Let the family of the prisoner pay for there health care or pay for there health insurance, not the taxpayers. Our schools are over crowded with too many students and many frustrated teachers. Proposition 187 should have been upheld by the courts which would have saved Taxpayers billions in reduced welfare and medical coverage for illegal’s and stopped the over crowding of our public schools. California needs to make the state friendlier to big business that will pay good salaries and benefits instead of minimum wage like Target and Wal-Mart with little or no benefits. California was once the "Golden State", now it's the 'Welfare State"! "

Watchdog Fred wrote on Jun 2, 2009 11:17 AM:

" Isn't Arnold planning on selling the Golden Gate Bridge along with San Quentin? "

Alihandero wrote on Jun 3, 2009 7:15 PM:

" Wonder what we could get for the Golden Gate Bridge? "

Watchdog Fred wrote on Jun 4, 2009 9:53 AM:

" To: ALIHANDERO HEY AMIGO,

PROBABLY ABOUT 100,000 WIC COUPONS! "

Thoughts I confess wrote on Jun 4, 2009 2:02 PM:

" At 200 million pounds of scrap metal, vintage 1939 AMERICAN steel mind you market price today $30 a pound...GOOGOL-ly!

I hate to think that any structure built in the last 20 years from cheap, inferior quality $11 per pound Chinese steel, will really ever be “works of art” or be considered American.

My sadness is that if the GG was to be sold, it would be another slap in the face...mountains of 1940 steel was used in the Twin Towers. It's a travesty when symbols of America become refuse, lucrative scraps of metal for dealers and brokers.

Individuals are making millions on this weak economy, weakness produced by this nations leaders who never protected our borders after the 9-11 incidents.

Today, U.S. citizens gradually blink an eye at such disorder and are dumb at its obligation to protection its national identity.

Tarnished? No, we are rusting with the high inclusion of impurities, elements of people without respect for law, parasitical and caustic to a country and its economy. Everybody wants to come to America but doesn’t really want to commit to this country. In the long haul their numbers will grow. Sic! "

Alihandero wrote on Jun 5, 2009 6:11 AM:

" Watchdog,

Forget about food stamp coupons! We are into the electronic welfare age (you don't have to know English to use).

They will probably use the free welfare "Golden Advantage" debit card to buy the sucka! "

watcher wrote on Jun 8, 2009 10:21 AM:

" I just do not understand why or when the liberals will see what they are doing to California. They keep running it into the ground. It must be their mind set. California is a welfare state. I have noticed that the Liberal people have no problem spending money other than theirs to support their give away programs. We are in a sad state of affairs, and no way out. But as King Obama said. We all need to sacrifice. Funny, I do not see him sacrificing. The conservatives will need to rise up to any level necessary to be heard. What will California do when they have more people on welfare than working. The workers will move out and leave this state. What will that do to the general fund. Hummm. perhaps it will bankrupt the state. Look were we are today. Sure not over flowing with funding. This state is in the worst shape I have seen in several decades. At the rate we are going we will be just like Mexico and many poor countries. Corruption running ramped (humm) and unreasonable laws. Have you ever asked yourself why California has more laws than any other state. "

manuel wrote on Jun 9, 2009 6:40 PM:

" The main reason the state of california is so broke are the prisons, they are costing the state billions of dollars, you have so many bleeding hearts crying for the prisoners to get better treatment, they forget that they cmmited a crime. they get better medical and schooling than people on the outside, and the guards have a very powerful union, which gives them a very good wage "

Watchdog Fred wrote on Jun 10, 2009 12:25 PM:

" To: Alihandero wrote on Jun 5, 2009 6:11 AM:

"They will probably use the free welfare "Golden Advantage" debit card to buy the sucka! "

Yeah, I keep forgetting we are an advanced society. Do we reward them with frequent flyer miles for using the debit card? Gee it seems they should get something more than just groceries. Afterall, we are paying the bill, we should be more generous and pass out freebies. Oh yeah we already do, at the WIC counters across Kings County. The biggest rip off for the dairy industry and the retailers, in the world. It increases the volume for producers which lowers their cost while putting twice the normal cost of milk in the registers of the local retailers. All compliments of Mr. and Mrs. Taxpayer. That is WIC in a nutshell. "

Watchdog Fred wrote on Jun 10, 2009 12:27 PM:

" To: Alihandero wrote on Jun 5, 2009 6:11 AM:

"They will probably use the free welfare "Golden Advantage" debit card to buy the sucka! "

If you want this problem solved layoff a bunch of those taking applications and hire more welfare fraud investigators who really investigate. When was the last Welfare Fraud case filed in this county, yet you and I know fraud goes on everyday at every retailer in this town. Investigate the recipients before, during and after they are deemed eligible and you will find many who are not eligible any longer. So prosecute them send a message and you will see the fraud begin to disappear for fear of being caught. "

Pete wrote on Jun 10, 2009 1:46 PM:

" Hey manuel, you Libs are the ones giving all the money to the prisoners plus 5 times that much to the illegals! "

SuziQ wrote on Jun 10, 2009 1:48 PM:

" Wonder why Scott Tucker and Keith Olbermann are so jealous of Rush Limbaugh. All both of them do is criticize Rush. "

Alihandero wrote on Jun 10, 2009 5:28 PM:

" The liberal progressive tax-and-spend giveaways and feel-good programs are the major cause of our state's cash flow problem.

Since CA. is an established left wing haven, what can really REALISTICALLY be accomplished?

Any workable suggestions, Folks? "

jeff wrote on Jun 11, 2009 10:44 AM:

" "Wonder why Scott Tucker and Keith Olbermann are so jealous of Rush Limbaugh. All both of them do is criticize Rush."

I guess this means every person here who has criticized Obama, Clinton, the Democratic Congress, me, Scott, Dandre, Dose etc are jealous of all of us. "

Watchdog Fred wrote on Jun 13, 2009 7:15 PM:

" To: jeff wrote on Jun 11, 2009 10:44 AM:

"I guess this means every person here who has criticized Obama, Clinton, the Democratic Congress, me, Scott, Dandre, Dose etc are jealous of all of us. "

No, what this demonstrates is the rest of us got it right! "




Advertisement


HOT TOPICS

> More Hot Topics


MORE LOCAL NEWS

Lemoore:

    Selma:

    Kingsburg:



    PHOTO GALLERIES

    "More Photos

    Sentinel Photos (134) Albums

    Hanford Luminaria
    Hanford Luminaria
    Friday, November, 20 2009
    (6) Photos
    Hanford High vs Dinuba Waterpolo Final
    Hanford High vs Dinuba Waterpolo Final
    Wednesday, November, 18 2009
    (13) Photos
    Fire on Hawk Street
    Fire on Hawk Street
    Wednesday, November, 18 2009
    (11) Photos

    Reader Submitted (7) Albums

    Vintage Hanford
    Vintage Hanford
    Monday, December, 15 2008
    (1) Photos
    Vacation Photos
    Vacation Photos
    Thursday, November, 20 2008
    (37) Photos
    Events
    Events
    Thursday, November, 20 2008
    (38) Photos

    More



    EMAIL UPDATES

    Sign up today to get all your local headlines delivered to your home or work e-mail address, so you don't miss the latest in breaking and local news.
    E-Mail:
    Daily News Updates
    Breaking News Alerts