Currently
54°
Showers

Advertisement





Opinion

CLASSIFIEDS


Advertisement


Free Ad

Place an ad
in print and online, 24/7 for free, select the Clean Sweep option. Unable to submit Real Estate, Services, and Business Investements at this time.

Get a Subscription


Map the Valley


Subscriber/
Reader Services

Subscribe Now
Contact Customer Service



Politics Today: Dialogue, not disruption, the prescription for health care reform

One of the greatest worries congressional staffers face when organizing a town hall meeting for their boss is that no one will attend it. Now they really have something to fear: organized gangs of partisan hecklers intent on stopping a national dialogue on health reform.

After spending thousands of dollars of government-paid “franked mail” to every constituent in a member’s district, blasting out faxes to the local media, assembling experts to answer difficult questions and posting reminders through Facebook and Twitter, encouraging citizens to attend these informative events takes time and money. So why are some folks hellbent on shutting them down? My answer: Republicans want to stifle debate and kill any attempt to reform health care during this session of Congress.

In a July 31 memo to House Republicans titled “A Very Hot Summer,” House Minority Leader John Boehner, R-Ohio, promised that “Our Democratic friends are going to feel the heat in August from the American people as a consequence of the massively flawed health care bill, and rightly so. ... Our work is far from over ... Our mission now is to keep it going.”

Three days later, Boehner posted a “Leader Alert” on his official Web site that crowed about Democratic congressmen being harassed and heckled during town hall meetings with their constituents. Boehner seemed particularly pleased with the Austin American Statesman account of the “angry reception” Rep. Lloyd Doggett, D-Texas, faced from a group that “overwhelmed the congressman as he moved through the crowd and into the parking lot.”

Meanwhile, FreedomWorks, chaired by former Republican House Majority Leader Dick Armey, is e-mailing 380,000 supporters this week with a link to an “August Recess Action Kit” and the call to arms: “Turn Up the Heat in August: Help Defeat ObamaCare.”

Reforming our nation’s health care system is too important and complex a topic for us to allow partisan agitators to be so disruptive. It’s a shame because no matter where you stand on the various proposals, this summer is a time to review and discuss the legislation that Congress will consider upon their return in the fall.

As Richard Nixon once noted, “We cannot learn from one another until we stop shouting at one another — until we speak quietly enough so that our words can be heard as well as our voices.”

Yes, of course hecklers are welcome to attend town hall meetings, but no member of Congress deserves to be heckled and harassed to the point of fearing personal harm. What is happening at the town hall meetings is frightening.

Have we abandoned all hope of bipartisanship? Do we really want our elected officials to demonize their opposition?

And are Republicans that desperate because it appears as though the economy is improving and Obama might just get the credit after they fought him tooth and nail?

These so-called hecklers should be encouraged to attend, rather than shut down, town hall meetings, if only to listen to fellow Americans who are fearful of losing their current health care or worried that their premiums will rise so much as to not be able to afford any at all.

Instead, these disruptive elements scream with one eye searching for the nearest TV camera. They seek confrontation that will distract from any meaningful dialogue between our elected leaders and their constituents.

What we need is a respectful and civilized debate. What we have are agitators who hung in effigy a likeness of Reps. Frank Kratovil Jr. (Md.) and Allen Boyd (Fla.) outside their district offices. Rep. Pete Sessions, who chairs the National Republican Congressional Committee, went so far as telling Politico that the time for polite town halls is now “over.” Republicans leaders should be held accountable for encouraging and promoting these disruptions.

We need a vigorous national debate, not intimidation, coercion and sowing seeds of discontent. This is all part of a well-orchestrated political campaign paid for by opponents of health care reform. They want the status quo, in new threads. However they dress it, it will leave the average American in rags. Cries of “socialism!” and “government-run health care” are scarecrows they raise to protect vested interests.

For now, these hecklers are just smoke and mirrors. Americans continue to demand the genuine change needed to afford to maintain the health care we have — and may one day lose.

We are all dead in the water with the current broken health care system. The president’s willingness to change the August deadline shows his commitment to “getting it right.” It’s a delay, not an end. The American people will have their reform. We all want better health care, and better health care we should demand — provided members of Congress don’t fall for the fear mongers.

Courage is what we all need now — courage to risk change after our best plans are put forward and debated.

Donna Brazile is a political commentator on CNN, ABC and NPR; contributing columnist to Roll Call, the newspaper of Capitol Hill; and former campaign manager for Al Gore.

POST A COMMENT

 

Hanfordsentinel.com encourages readers to engage in civil conversation with their neighbors. Comments that are submitted are not posted to the site immediately. They go into a queue to be moderated and may take several hours to be reviewed, particularly if they are posted after normal office hours.

We reserve the right to remove comments in total that violate our code of conduct. If you want to report a violation, please e-mail editor@HanfordSentinel.com

For more information please read our Terms of use, and Rules of the Road.

 


Please log in to post comments
*Member ID:
*Password:
  Forgot Your Password?
 
If you don't have an account you can create one for free by clicking the link below.
CREATE ACCOUNT
The following are comments from the readers. In no way do they represent the views of the Hanford Sentinel

Devil's Advocate wrote on Aug 8, 2009 1:49 AM:

" Maybe they are genuinely upset because they have taken the time to read the bill, have seen the unbelievably high price tag, have understood that it includes the greatest expansion of abortion since Roe v Wade through direct government subsidy, and leaves seniors and the helpless in danger of being encouraged to euthanize themselves.

Maybe they seen the videos of Obama saying we need a single-payer health care system.

Maybe they have seen an attempt to completely shatter an existing system that might be fixed with simple measures like tort reform or caps on medical malpractice, measures that weren't even discussed by the reformers with their agenda to "fundamentally change the United States".

I've never seen Americans more upset with their government than right now - and it didn't take anyone organizing them to make it happen. It just took watching the news, and witnessing tyranny. "

pnotes wrote on Aug 8, 2009 1:57 PM:

" What congress needs to do is to let the people see the bills page for page and give us a chance to discuss all the issues. Right now we are limited to access to all the details.

There should also be a council of doctors, nurses, researchers, etc appointed to write a new health care program. NOT CONGRESS! Let the people who work in the field of medicine and health hammer out a health plan, not congress. "

Alihandero wrote on Aug 14, 2009 4:35 PM:

" Hey Devil's Advocate, you are right on once again!

You said:

"I've never seen Americans more upset with their government than right now - and it didn't take anyone organizing them to make it happen. It just took watching the news, and witnessing tyranny. "

True.

However, it DID take a 'community organizer' with the name of Barack Hussein Obama II to unite those who were once derided as being America's 'silent majority.'

Remember the old liberal mantra: “Power to the People?”

Guess the liberals and socialistas don’t much like that phrase anymore! "

SJT wrote on Aug 14, 2009 11:19 PM:

" This should help to understand why he's our president:

http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/21134540/vp/32421468#32421468 "

SJT wrote on Aug 15, 2009 10:44 AM:

" pnotes: google hr3200 - there's your bill. "

dose wrote on Aug 15, 2009 2:24 PM:

" Here is a link to the entire House Bill, I would love for someone to show me where it calls for unprecedented abortion or death panels.

http://www.opencongress.org/bill/111-h3200/text "

Alihandero wrote on Aug 15, 2009 5:56 PM:

" SJT wrote on Aug 14, 2009 11:19 PM:
"This should help to understand why he's our president...(msnbc link)

Sorry to inform you SJT that it's not all as black and white as you would have us to believe...

...or is it?

Perhaps it's just time that the real American majority speaks up against the lies and false promises of the hype some - but not all - of us bought into last year.

That's democracy, SJT. "

Alihandero wrote on Aug 16, 2009 5:06 PM:

" This is from the stimulus rah-rah topic but it fits here just as well, so...

We American citizens AND those pesky Republicans caused this today, friend SJT:


***RETREAT: TEAM OBAMA DROPS 'PUBLIC OPTION'

. . . Government-Run Health Insurance Plan 'Not Essential' . . .

"Health and Human Services Secretary Kathleen Sebelius said providing citizens with the option of government-run insurance isn't essential to the Obama administration's proposed overhaul of U.S. health care."

(Sources:http://www.bloomberg.com/apps/news?pid=20601087&sid=aRqy6w7DFAB0 . . . http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/us_health_care_overhaul . . . Drudge Report . . . )

Our President just up and changed his mind, right?

Democracy at work, SJT! "

RobertD wrote on Aug 18, 2009 1:00 PM:

" I hope Ms. Brazile is similarly outraged at the now common tactic amongst the democrats to hold these so-called townhall meetings in union halls (or other home turf areas) and headquarters right after a union meeting so that "their" people will fill the few hundred seats available and keep out those who have ligitimate questions about Obomacare. Most of us have real jobs and do not have the time to read the gargantuan bill; however, the media (lib and con) have been reporting on these death panel provisions, so I would think it must be there somewhere...or maybe not since the latest interent news buzz is that such provisions have been scrapped. So, dose, how could they be scrapped if they never existed? "

Paul wrote on Aug 18, 2009 3:55 PM:

" Devil's Advocate wrote on Aug 8, 2009 1:49 AM:

" because they have taken the time to read the bill."

Sooo many republican senators said they need more time to read the bill and now you are saying that ordinary citizens have read it already. Huh??

"have understood that it includes the greatest expansion of abortion since Roe v Wade through direct government subsidy"... what does that mean?? That every woman and teenage girl in America can now get one. Gee.

"and leaves seniors and the helpless in danger of being encouraged to euthanize themselves." That comment can be traced back to Sen.Grassley and his "Death Panels."


You have read straight from the dick armey and their pharmaceutical and insurance companies playbook. The ones that ARE REALLY BEHIND this so called grass roots movement. Armey was also behind the tea party movement. Gee, where have they gone??

Oh, and then there is the mention of cost. Where were all of you when for 7 years bush wanted and got BLANK CHECKS for his wars in Iraq and Afgan??? "

Paul wrote on Aug 18, 2009 4:16 PM:

" Alihandero wrote on Aug 15, 2009 5:56 PM:

"Perhaps it's just time that the real American majority speaks up against the lies and false promises"

Are you invoking the ghost of spiro agnew and his "silent majority???"

The only real Americans I've seen speak up AGAIN are the pharmaceutical and insurance companies that don't want ANY reform.

I think these lobbyist LOVE you guys. Armey make MILLIONS in fees and is suing the US gov't to get himself off social security. If I had his MILLIONS IN THE BANK and with the lobby groups he belongs to that will support him and his family FOREVER, I'd sue the gov't too. Tell them to keep their 1000. dollars a month when he can make that in ONE HOUR.

And when these same people that have guns strapped to their sides and with the same phrase that Timothy McVeigh had on his tee shirt about "Water the Tree of Liberty" get old, they will be asking for some gov't assistance.

Your cops are making their point ali. just ask Darryl Jenkins. Getting closer. "

SJT wrote on Aug 18, 2009 7:16 PM:

" ...real American majority, Ali? Could you peel that onion back a little here for us who're not privy to what appears as some "code"? Am hoping also that you could better define some specifics regarding lies you mention in the post.. "

Watchdog Fred wrote on Aug 18, 2009 8:21 PM:

" To: Alihandero wrote on Aug 15, 2009 5:56 PM:

Once again a point well made a point well proven. Thank You Alihandero for the intestinal fortitude to speak your mind and provide evidence of the unthinkable disaster some refer to as Healthcare reform. Who are they kidding the only form to Healthcare is we the Insurance Companies take your money.

The reason the government hates this current program is it see's another opportunity to take our money by force and is grasping at it and some are too blind to see it coming.

We didn't see Pearl Harbor coming either. "

jeff wrote on Aug 19, 2009 11:58 AM:

" RobertD,

What they "Scrapped" was the text that some people have used to misrepresent the truth and fabricate the entire death panel story. There are no death panels in the proposed bill. There are however panels of folks who work for insurance companies who do decide what coverage to give to someone who is terminally ill.

It's section 1233 of H.R. 3200, I work and have a family yet still found enough time to read at least that much of the bill. If someone doesn't have enough time to read it they are being lazy pure and simple. All it does is say people have a right to end of life consultation. Insurance companies do this today and Newt, Beck and Palin actually criticized our current health care for not doing more of this less than a year ago. Why is it a problem now? Maybe because they didn't think of it first.

Sarah Palin is a lying hypocrite, http://www.gov.state.ak.us/archive.php?id=1094&type=6 "

Paul wrote on Aug 19, 2009 1:15 PM:

" RobertD wrote:
"a common tactic amongst the democrats

Most of us have real jobs and do not have the time to read the gargantuan bill;

the media (lib and con) have been reporting on these death panel provisions, so I would think..."

It amazes me how you can already "think" and not KNOW ANYTHING about what you are commenting on.

A "common tactic" among republicans is to bus people around that WILL GUARANTEE TOUGH QUESTIONS and shut all dialogue DOWN. Period.

You say you don't have "time to read the gargantuan bill" D.A. wants to know why?? You are behind the game. He/she says that is the percise reason why some many "Americans" are upset and shouting down their representatives. I wonder if D.A. has read the bill and which version since one hasn't been passed yet. Last I heard, there were several bills pending.

The death provision panels?? Fox news says there's one. That the US is going to start killing grandpas and grandmas. GOD ALMIGHTY!

The rest of the UNITED STATES will tell you that it's a living will clause. PERIOD. "

Paul wrote on Aug 19, 2009 1:54 PM:

" Watchdog Fred wrote on Aug 18, 2009 8:21 PM:

"Once again a point well made a point well proven.

The reason the government hates this current program is it see's another opportunity to take our money by force.

We didn't see Pearl Harbor coming either. "

What point was proven?? Huh?? He throws up and pastes headlines and citations and you say he has proven a point. He has proven that he is willing to fight ANY FACTS with feelings. What HE feels. NOT FACTS. True republicans.

Taking our money by force??? Oh, you mean like when cheney wanted to send the US Military to ARREST suspected terrorist in Buffalo. Is that who YOU think is after our MONEY.

Go out and enjoy what's left of summer. "

Alihandero wrote on Aug 20, 2009 5:51 AM:

" Thanks for your kind words, Watchdog.

Leave it desperate liberal "Paul" to inject race into an otherwise color-blind discussion of healthcare.

Patently pathetic and not cool...

And remember, liberal Democrat Obama supporter Ms. Brazille says this:

"Yes, of course hecklers are welcome to attend town hall meetings."

Democracy at work, folks! "

Deb wrote on Aug 20, 2009 9:57 AM:

" The news always glamorizes the extreme - not so long ago when Palin was inciting the extremists so many posters here were right there self assured that McCain/Palin were going to win. They pointed to the MSM.

Once again, this is happening. But it's not reflective of the majority. Are there problems with the health care bill - certainly. Will there ever be a bill that meets everyone's needs, no.

What's more troubling to me is the congressional representatives in both parties with the insurance companies supporting them through donations is astounding.

I've always been against lobbys and PACs. How exactly can those congressional reps bite the hand that feeds them?

Follow the money... Where's the outrage when the insurance industry is spending billions of dollars a year to line congressional reps pockets?

It's the insurance premium increases year after year that pay for that. It's the denials of coverage that pay for it. It's the decreased services that pays for it.

Yea, we show the world just how smart we are... In the arena of health care we are an embarrassment. "

Skip wrote on Aug 20, 2009 1:15 PM:

" At least we can all agree on one thing, the current Obama health care package is BAD for America. When I see some of the supporters on TV, I have to the think of that great Ricky Nelson song, "Poor Little Fools". "

Paul wrote on Aug 21, 2009 5:20 PM:

" Alihandero wrote on Aug 20, 2009 5:51 AM:

" Thanks for your kind words, Watchdog.

Because Paul is not cool...

I'm sorry. can I buy you a beer? "

Paul wrote on Aug 21, 2009 5:31 PM:

" Skip wrote on Aug 20, 2009 1:15 PM:

" At least we can all agree on one thing, the current Obama health care package is BAD for America.

Yeah, if your primary source of ALL NEWS is form fox, hanitty or beck... ahhh and of course rush. I bet some of you even belong to the tea party. birthers, and think President Obama is not a US citizen and should be deported to Mex... oh sorry wrong country.

Oh hell, either way, deport him.
Beside he wants to implement Nazi death policies...

dick armey, pharmaceutical and insurance companies... they are the ONLY ones who think reform is a bad idea. "

Alihandero wrote on Aug 22, 2009 5:13 AM:

" Wow!

Deb says:

"Yea, we show the world just how smart we are... In the arena of health care we are an embarrassment."

And you wonder why liberals and their ilk keep losing the moral high ground?

America is - once again - SO garl-darn BAD and only the Democrats can change it.

That kind of continued thinking is so demeaning to this marvelous country, Folks! "

Watchdog Fred wrote on Aug 22, 2009 12:49 PM:

" Any topic that may interfere with or take monies from Donna Brazile's favorite give-a- way programs will obviously be noted by her in her column. If it says Democrat not Democratic she is all over it like white on rice. If it stipulates a reaction to the action causing actual change, she wants nothing to do with it. Point Blank!

Her biased opinion matches many who choose to blog here and swear they are trying to benefit Mr. and Mrs. Joe Citizen. When they are most assuredly working on their own agendas at will while toasting their success as liberal leftist.
Enough said. "

ToldYouSo wrote on Sep 3, 2009 9:20 PM:

" Why does Obama and the Dems keep hiding that pesky birth certificate? Let's see Bill Clinton committed perjury so maybe ..... "

ToldYouSo wrote on Sep 3, 2009 9:28 PM:

" What do you really think Paul, all of us Republicans will just blindly support this poorly written plan and give up our freedom of speech rights just to make an inexperienced new president look good. The only thing the Democratic party is good at is finding new ways to waste Republican's money. Also if you need a lesson in telling lies just look at the Clinton administration, or do you think only Republicans can tell lies because that is what CNN told you. "




Advertisement


HOT TOPICS

> More Hot Topics


MORE LOCAL NEWS

Lemoore:

    Selma:

    Kingsburg:



    PHOTO GALLERIES

    "More Photos

    Sentinel Photos (134) Albums

    Hanford Luminaria
    Hanford Luminaria
    Friday, November, 20 2009
    (6) Photos
    Hanford High vs Dinuba Waterpolo Final
    Hanford High vs Dinuba Waterpolo Final
    Wednesday, November, 18 2009
    (13) Photos
    Fire on Hawk Street
    Fire on Hawk Street
    Wednesday, November, 18 2009
    (11) Photos

    Reader Submitted (7) Albums

    Vintage Hanford
    Vintage Hanford
    Monday, December, 15 2008
    (1) Photos
    Vacation Photos
    Vacation Photos
    Thursday, November, 20 2008
    (37) Photos
    Events
    Events
    Thursday, November, 20 2008
    (38) Photos

    More



    EMAIL UPDATES

    Sign up today to get all your local headlines delivered to your home or work e-mail address, so you don't miss the latest in breaking and local news.
    E-Mail:
    Daily News Updates
    Breaking News Alerts