Currently
48°
Showers

Advertisement





Opinion

CLASSIFIEDS


Advertisement


Free Ad

Place an ad
in print and online, 24/7 for free, select the Clean Sweep option. Unable to submit Real Estate, Services, and Business Investements at this time.

Get a Subscription


Map the Valley


Subscriber/
Reader Services

Subscribe Now
Contact Customer Service



Local Guest Commentary: Are delta smelt fish more important than people?

People might be surprised to learn Congress's ESA (Endangered Species Act) Laws unfortunately do value fish more than people. The ESA law has been selectively used and abused by environmentalist and politicians as a political sledgehammer to depress economic development in rural America and destroy the equal protection principles, applying to one and all, contained in the Declaration of Independence: Life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness.

In 1978, the Supreme Court ruled, in Tennessee Valley Authority versus Hill, that under Congress's ESA laws, the Federal Government was compelled to protect the snail darter, a tiny minnow, over the needs of people downstream of Tellico Dam in Tennessee. The Supreme Court ruling confirmed that the intent of Congress's ESA laws was to preserve listed species "whatever the cost."

The God squad was asked to intervene but refused to do so. Congress then took action and waived the ESA to allow continued operation of Tellico Dam.

In 2002, a federal court ruled that drinking water originally intended for 500,000 residents of Albuquerque, N.M., should be diverted to protect the silvery minnow-a listed species under Congress's ESA laws.

Once again the Supreme Court ruled: "In enacting the ESA, Congress required the federal courts to give greater protection to endangered species over human interest." The federal court further declared that "the government's first duty is to the fish."

But guess what? Rather than letting Albuquerque, N.M. run out of water in 2003 Congress again did the right thing. Congress passed legislation in 2003 suspending enforcement of ESA laws in order to protect Albuquerque's continued access to water.

This brings us to the current water crisis in California. The fgederal courts have consistently ruled it was Congress's intent that even water destined for California farms and California cities should be sent to the ocean to benefit species like the "delta smelt."

In reviewing the enforcement of the ESA laws for the delta smelt, the situation is nearly identical to the silvery minnow and the snail darter cases. Why then hasn't Congress treated the Central Valley of California equally by temporarily suspending the ESA? Congress did this in 1978 and for New Mexico residents in 2003.

One Valley congressman, Devin Nunes, has repeatedly introduced legislation to protect the valley and the US domestic food supply. Nune's legislation is nearly identical to legislation passed into law by Congress to benefit Albuquerque residents. Unfortunately he has been stopped by some of the same politicians who voted for the New Mexico water legislation in 2003.

Valley and California congressional representatives are not united, as some have voted against legislation that would solve the Valley water crisis.

The efforts to restore our water deliveries continue to be blocked by partisan politics in Congress, more surprisingly even by our local Valley congressmen, Jim Costa and Dennis Cardoza.

Our two local Valley congressional representatives may deny the charge, but the facts speak for themselves. On July 14, Congressman Cardoza voted against three different amendments that would have turned on the delta pumps and restore water deliveries to the Central Valley.

Bay area congressional representatives Nancy Pelosi, George Miller, Sam Farr, Mike Honda and Mike Thompson all voted for the New Mexico water legislation in 2003. Now in 2009 they have basically declared war against California Central Valley farms and cities by testifying and voting against the Nunes legislation that would restore our water deliveries.

Then on July 23, both congressmen Jim Costa and Dennis Cardoza voted against legislation that would have allowed Congress to immediately consider legislation to turn the delta water pumps on and keep them on. Despite being co-sponsors of the legislation, they voted against the bill.

I guess Costa and Cardoza can continue issuing press releases claiming they co-sponsored legislation to turn on the pumps. But will they tell people they voted against the legislation they co-sponsored?

By voting against the legislation, Costa and Cardoza voted against the best interest of Valley residents and have assisted Bay Area the politicians who want our water, Nancy Pelosi, George Miller, Diane Feinstein and Barbara Boxer.

Instead of staying in Washington to solve the water crisis, Costa and Cardoza decided to let Valley residents continue to suffer while they went on their summer vacations.

Congress passed the laws. Congress can change the laws, or we need to change Congress.

Waymire is a resident of Hanford. He has co-chaired the local Farm Bureau Water Committee and attended numerous water meetings with politicians and natural resource agencies in California and Washington D.C.

(Sept. 12, 2009)

POST A COMMENT

 

Hanfordsentinel.com encourages readers to engage in civil conversation with their neighbors. Comments that are submitted are not posted to the site immediately. They go into a queue to be moderated and may take several hours to be reviewed, particularly if they are posted after normal office hours.

We reserve the right to remove comments in total that violate our code of conduct. If you want to report a violation, please e-mail editor@HanfordSentinel.com

For more information please read our Terms of use, and Rules of the Road.

 


Please log in to post comments
*Member ID:
*Password:
  Forgot Your Password?
 
If you don't have an account you can create one for free by clicking the link below.
CREATE ACCOUNT
The following are comments from the readers. In no way do they represent the views of the Hanford Sentinel

Sid wrote on Sep 11, 2009 7:44 PM:

" Excellent article! Thanks Russell.

The same Jim Costa who only met with government employees instead of his REAL constituents last month...where was OUR chance to discuss health care "reform" with him? He didn't give us a chance, he avoided us.

No doubt he will vote against his constituents wishes again, which like the water issue Russell described here, he is beholden to fellow party politicians who have little regard for the Central Valley.

Lets re-direct Hetch Hetcy reservoir water to it's closer Central Valley needed uses and let San Francisco drink from the ocean that surrounds it on three sides. Desalinating it is up to them... "

Alihandero wrote on Sep 12, 2009 6:36 AM:

" If the Obama Administration wasn't playing grabache with shoving its vision of healthcare down our throats, couldn't some executive order or proposed congressional bill or such demote the Delta Smelt to it's rightful place in the 'survival of the fittest' food chain?

And perhaps he water of life could flow back to the Central Valley... "

the oracle wrote on Sep 17, 2009 5:40 PM:

" I had a great pithy comment on Costa and his cowardly ways in hiding from his constituents....But alas the Sentinel again refused to print opposing viewpoints "

ToldYouSo wrote on Sep 17, 2009 8:26 PM:

" Well, we know all our Democrat friends are voting fish. "

jeff wrote on Sep 18, 2009 2:57 PM:

" "Local Guest Commentary: Are delta smelt fish more important than people?"

Depends on who the people are. "

Alihandero wrote on Sep 18, 2009 6:12 PM:

" eff wrote on Sep 18, 2009 2:57 PM:
"Local Guest Commentary: Are delta smelt fish more important than people?"

…"Depends on who the people are. "

And just WHO are those people, “jeff?”

Why, simply, they are just plain people,

And you know "jeff" that people who need people,

They really are the luckiest people in the world! "

Watchdog Fred wrote on Sep 19, 2009 3:25 AM:

" BOY IF YOU LIKE FOREIGN OIL!

YOUR GONNA LOVE FOREIGN FOOD! "

manuel wrote on Sep 19, 2009 9:12 AM:

" Told you so Well as we all know, the last administration [ the Republicans] failed to protect the farmers, now as usual they tend to blame everyone but them selfs, they had 8 years to help, but wars were more important "

the oracle wrote on Sep 19, 2009 9:33 AM:

" In all seriousness, I honestly believe that "talking" about this is NOT going to bring about the desired effects of bringing water to the farmers. The Governor, in what I believe are a sign of things to come on many issues, is going to have to invoke the 10th amendment, IE states rights in saving his state. He should announce that he is sending a contingent of state national guardsmen to the pumps, with orders to ensure that the pumps turn on/stay on as needed. He should also notify the federal Govt of same. This is the ONLY way that this issue is going to come to a head and force some resolution. The federal Govt has shown that they are willing to allow an entire portion of the state to crumble and blow away in favor of a bait fish "

ToldYouSo wrote on Sep 19, 2009 10:38 PM:

" We only had one successful foreign attack on our country in the last 8 years. That attack was planned out completely on Clinton's watch, but did take place during Bush's first few months before he had time to make security changes that may have caught onto the plan. Bush successfully prevented any further attacks in our country so Manuel yes, keeping our country safe did distract Bush for most of his 8 years and was very important. At least he didn't spend half his presidency sneaking off to his private library during business hours to commit adultry then tie up government attorneys and secret service staff trying to cover it up. We live in a Democrat controlled state and have a Democrat controlled house, senate, and President. The water problem this year all took place under Obama's watch so you and your political party can Suck it Up and take some blame now. "

ToldYouSo wrote on Sep 19, 2009 10:42 PM:

" I like the Oracle's idea on taking over the pumps, but this is a Federal water project, Federal court order, and Federal laws related to protecting the stupid yet tasty fish. Sadly, Arnold has a snow balls chance in hell of actually taking over the pumping stations. 10th Amendment won't help in this case, what we need is the Democrat controlled congress and President to pull out their heads and actually fix the problem they caused. "

manuel wrote on Sep 20, 2009 10:49 AM:

" To the Oracle No truer words have been spoken, the governor has the power to restore the flow of water to the farmers if he so desired, hear that Told You SO "

ToldYouSo wrote on Sep 21, 2009 5:52 PM:

" Manuel, like usual, you are mis-informed and just making excuses for your political party failing to do the right thing. Given the current issues impacting America you better get used to making excuses for them. "

ToldYouSo wrote on Sep 23, 2009 6:56 PM:

" Manuel read this:

"An amendment offered by South Carolina Sen. Jim DeMint Tuesday night to suspend delta pumping restrictions to the San Joaquin Valley failed on a party line vote.

The vote was 61-36, with one Republican joining Democrats to vote against it"

To translate this the Democrat reps picked fish over people. Just like I told you they would do. "

Watchdog Fred wrote on Sep 25, 2009 5:02 PM:

" It's not a question of could Arnold do it, it is a question if Arnold has the necessary equipment to do it and stand up to the Federal Government for the sake of the people of California. "

ToldYouSo wrote on Sep 25, 2009 6:16 PM:

" Martha stood up to the Federal Government and we all know what happened to her. "

Paul wrote on Sep 25, 2009 11:52 PM:

" ToldYouSo wrote on Sep 19, 2009 10:38 PM:

" We only had one successful foreign attack on our country in the last 8 years. That attack was planned out completely on Clinton's watch, but did take place during Bush's first few months before he had time to make security changes that may have caught onto the plan"

He had 8 MONTHS. And there we go again. Blaming Billy about a plan that was done during his watch.

But of course, we don't dare say that they HIT DURING GEORGIES WATCH, DO WE!

"The water problem this year all took place under Obama's watch so you and your political party can Suck it Up and take some blame now. "

And we can now blame President Obama for the STATE PROBLEMS in Cali.

Toldyouso... sorry, you can't have it both ways. Some like you want the GOV'T to STAY OUT of state matters and now you want President Obama to do something FOR the state.

Sorry, you can't have your cake and eat it to. Wonder if that's a quote by Churchill.

Oh, one attack was enough! "

ToldYouSo wrote on Sep 26, 2009 4:56 PM:

" Paul you are back with some energy, but I do feel the Federal Government is responsible for fixing the problems they directly caused. It was a federal court that stopped the water not a state court. It was also related to federal environmental laws not state laws, so you really can't hide from the fact that the Democrat controlled government has failed to act on the side of people over fish. Painful I know, but maybe someday you will be able to see through the lies your political party is telling you and news flash, the Democrat controlled congress supported Bush's war efforts which is also a fact you want to pretend didn't exist. We also know the terrorist attack was planned out before Bush and that he did act swiftly and decisively after it to prevent any other attacks. Too bad for us Clinton didn't follow up on his failed attack on Bin Laden or do you deny that attack ever took place and failed. "

ToldYouSo wrote on Oct 5, 2009 8:09 PM:

" I do find it disturbing that Bill Clinton was too busy fondling in the library to notice a major terrorist plan developing right under his nose... and where was Gore, trying to figure out why we warm up in the summer. "

zlusth wrote on Nov 30, 2009 1:17 PM:

" It is unfortunate that california is going through a drought and that farmers are suffering. However, please don't be so short sighted!

The water isn't being cut off to save only a little fish. A whole ecosystem is at risk which could cause the loss of many more job such as the salmon fishing industry.

Do me a favor a do a little research about the Fertile Cresent (the birth place of agriculture). What was once called the Fertile Cresent is now called the middle east! Over irrigation and degregation of the enviroment cause the place to become a desert. Now NO ONE can grow.

You honestly think this is about a fish? It is about Jobs. Thank god some people are thinking longterm about jobs and food for future generation! I'm sorry about the hardship. Its a tough time for everyone. "




Advertisement


HOT TOPICS

> More Hot Topics


MORE LOCAL NEWS

Lemoore:

    Selma:

    Kingsburg:



    PHOTO GALLERIES

    "More Photos

    Sentinel Photos (185) Albums

    Kings County Academic Decathlon
    Kings County Academic Decathlon
    Monday, February, 8 2010
    (8) Photos
    Taoist Temple Tour
    Taoist Temple Tour
    Monday, February, 8 2010
    (9) Photos
    Hanford West vs Golden West Boys Basketball
    Hanford West vs Golden West Boys Basketball
    Monday, February, 8 2010
    (10) Photos

    Reader Submitted (7) Albums

    Vintage Hanford
    Vintage Hanford
    Monday, December, 15 2008
    (1) Photos
    Vacation Photos
    Vacation Photos
    Thursday, November, 20 2008
    (39) Photos
    Events
    Events
    Thursday, November, 20 2008
    (38) Photos

    More



    EMAIL UPDATES

    Sign up today to get all your local headlines delivered to your home or work e-mail address, so you don't miss the latest in breaking and local news.
    E-Mail:
    Daily News Updates
    Breaking News Alerts